Skip to content

Online Safety

A ten-minute account checkup before holiday shopping

By Shreya Bhatt · · 7 min read

A ten-minute account checkup before holiday shopping
On this page
  1. 1. Turn on card alerts (two minutes)
  2. 2. Pick the card you'll shop with (one minute)
  3. 3. Fix the passwords on the stores you'll actually use (three minutes)
  4. 4. Turn on two-step sign-in where your card is saved (two minutes)
  5. 5. Look at what's saved (one minute)
  6. 6. Practice the address habit (one minute)
  7. Gift cards, from both sides
  8. The checkup, on one screen

Thanksgiving week is when a lot of people sign in to shopping accounts they haven't touched since last December. Those accounts have been sitting there all along with a saved card, a home address and a password chosen years ago, and some of them were exposed in breaches nobody wrote to you about.

An account at a big store is a payment method with a login on top. Whoever gets in can ship an order to a new address, spend a stored gift card balance and read your order history, which says a lot about where you live and what you buy. Retail accounts are attractive for a dull reason: they tend to have old passwords, no second step and a card ready to use.

The checkup below fixes most of that before Black Friday, which falls on November 27. Six steps, about ten minutes, in order of how much each one protects you.

Privacy toolkit for this job

Picked from published documentation and reviews, not our own testing. We earn a commission from some services we link to. The full Privacy kit

1. Turn on card alerts (two minutes)

Open your card issuer's app, not a text or an email, and find the alerts or notifications settings. Turn on an alert for every purchase if the issuer offers it. If it doesn't, choose alerts for online purchases, for anything over a small amount you pick, and for international charges. Push notifications inside the issuer's own app beat text alerts, because texts are exactly what scammers imitate.

Do it for every card you might use, including debit cards and the one in your wallet you forgot about. An alert doesn't stop a fraudulent charge. It turns a problem you would have found on next month's statement into one you find the same evening, while it is still small and easy to dispute.

A warning that comes with alerts: fake fraud alerts were among the top text scams in the FTC's analysis of reports from 2024. The usual version is a message about a big purchase you didn't make, written to get you to call a number or tap a link. A real alert lives in the issuer's app. If a text says your card was used and asks you to respond, call the number printed on the back of the card instead.

2. Pick the card you'll shop with (one minute)

The FTC's advice on online shopping is plain: paying by credit card best protects you if something goes wrong. Here is what federal law gives you with each way of paying, as the FTC summarizes it.

How you pay If the number is stolen or misused If the order never arrives or is wrong
Credit card You aren't responsible for charges you didn't authorize when only the number was taken, and at most 50 dollars if the card itself was lost You can dispute the charge with the issuer
Debit card Your protection shrinks the longer you wait to report, and the money is already out of your account while the bank looks into it Ask your bank what it offers; the federal dispute right for billing errors applies to credit cards
Gift card, wire transfer, payment app or crypto Very hard to recover Very hard to recover

So pick one credit card for all your online holiday shopping. One card means one statement to watch, and if the number leaks, one card to replace. If your issuer offers virtual card numbers (a separate number tied to your account that you can lock or delete), use one for any store you are trying for the first time.

3. Fix the passwords on the stores you'll actually use (three minutes)

Don't try to fix every account you have ever opened. That is a job for the quiet days after the holidays. Write down the four or five stores you will really buy from, plus the email account those stores send receipts and reset links to.

Start with the email account, because anyone who controls it can reset every store password on your list. Then, for each store, sign in by typing the address yourself, and change any password you have used anywhere else or made up before you had a password manager. Our password strength check shows roughly how long a candidate would hold up against guessing software, and it runs entirely in your browser.

A password manager makes this step quick, because it creates and remembers a different password for each store. The one built into your phone or browser is fine. If you want one that works across every device and browser you use, NordPass is one standalone option. We mention it based on what the company publishes about its features and on published reviews, not on testing of our own.

4. Turn on two-step sign-in where your card is saved (two minutes)

Most large stores and payment apps offer two-step sign-in, and some offer passkeys, which can't be phished because they only work on the real site. Find the account's security or "login and security" settings and turn on the strongest option offered. An authenticator app beats a text message code, and a passkey beats both. The differences, and how to set them all up in one evening, are in my piece on password managers, passkeys and two-step codes.

If you only have time for one store, choose the one with your card saved and the most money going through it.

5. Look at what's saved (one minute)

While you are signed in to each store, look at three lists.

  • Saved cards. Remove cards from stores you buy from once a year. Typing the number again next time takes thirty seconds, and it means one less place holding it in the meantime.
  • Saved addresses. An address you don't recognize is a sign someone else has been in the account. Delete it, change the password and look at the orders.
  • Recent orders. Report anything you didn't buy to the store's support team through its own site or app, the same day.

Your browser may hold cards too. Google's Chrome help pages explain that clearing your browsing data doesn't delete payment details stored in Google Wallet, so cards saved that way have to be removed in Wallet itself. If you once saved a card on a shared family computer, take it off there as well.

6. Practice the address habit (one minute)

Fake stores and lookalike sign-in pages usually reach people in one of three ways: a link in a text or email, an ad on social media, or a sponsored result at the top of a search. The FBI warned in December 2022 that criminals buy search ads that impersonate real brands. Its advice still holds: check the address before you click, and type a business's address into your browser rather than searching for it.

Bookmark the stores from step 3 now and use those bookmarks all season. If a page asks you to sign in and your password manager doesn't offer to fill the password, stop and read the address, because managers fill passwords only on the site they were saved for. The padlock beside the address means the connection is encrypted, nothing more. Scam sites have padlocks too.

For a store you have never bought from, the checks in our 20-minute routine for vetting a company before you pay work just as well on an online shop: registration, complaints, the age of the website and how it wants to be paid.

Privacy kit

Chosen from specifications, policies and published reviews; we have not tested these ourselves. More in the Privacy kit

Gift cards, from both sides

Gift cards are a big part of holiday spending and a favorite of holiday scammers, and they carry none of the protections in the table above.

When you buy one, the FTC says to check that the protective stickers are on the card, that nothing looks tampered with and that the PIN on the back isn't showing. A card that was tampered with on the rack can be emptied before the person you give it to ever uses it. Keep the receipt with the card until the balance is spent.

When someone asks you to pay with one, stop there. In the FTC's words, "only scammers will tell you to buy a gift card" and hand over the numbers on the back. The stories change: a friend or relative with an emergency, a caller who says they are from a government agency or tech support, a utility threatening to cut off service, an online seller that accepts nothing else. The FTC's online shopping guidance says never to buy from a seller that insists on gift cards, wire transfers, payment apps or cryptocurrency, because those payments are so hard to get back.

If you already sent gift card numbers to a scammer, contact the company that issued the card right away and ask for your money back. The FTC notes that some issuers are able to help. Keep the card and the store receipt, and report what happened at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

The checkup, on one screen

  • Alerts on, in every card issuer's app
  • One credit card for online shopping
  • A new, unique password on your email and your top stores
  • Two-step sign-in on any store with a saved card
  • Old cards and unfamiliar addresses removed
  • Bookmarks for the stores you actually use
  • No gift cards as payment, for anyone, for any reason

If nothing else, do the first two tonight. They take three minutes, and they protect every purchase you make between now and New Year's Day.

Your next three steps

  1. See how long your current password pattern would last in the password strength check; it runs in your browser.
  2. Move every account to its own password in a manager such as NordPass.
  3. Put a security key on your email first, then the bank, and keep a second key as the backup.