YubiKey vs passkey: do you still need a security key?

On this page
The YubiKey vs passkey question sounds like a choice between two rival products. It isn't. A YubiKey can hold passkeys. The real choice is where your passkey lives: synced across your phone and laptop by Apple, Google, Microsoft or a password manager, or locked inside a small piece of hardware on your key ring. Both kinds stop the fake login pages that defeat passwords and text codes. They differ in who can get to the key, what it depends on, and how you recover when something goes missing.
Most people can use synced passkeys and stop there. A few accounts deserve a hardware key as well, and the reason has more to do with recovery than with security.
Privacy toolkit for this job
- NordPassOne unique password per account, filled only on the real site.Start with NordPass
Picked from published documentation and reviews, not our own testing. We earn a commission from some services we link to. The full Privacy kit
The two side by side
| Synced passkey | Passkey on a security key | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the private key lives | Your credential manager, copied to each device you sign in to | Inside the key, and nowhere else |
| What protects it | Your device's screen lock, plus the cloud account that syncs it | The key itself, plus a PIN you set on it |
| Resists phishing | Yes | Yes |
| Lost phone | Your other devices still have it, and a new phone gets it back from the account | Your spare key still works, if you registered one |
| Can it be copied or backed up | Yes, by design | No |
| How many you can store | No practical limit | Up to 100 on current YubiKeys, 25 on older ones |
| Works on a computer you don't own | Usually, by scanning a code with your phone | Yes, plug it in or tap it |
The FIDO Alliance, the industry group behind passkeys, describes both as phishing resistant, because a passkey only ever answers the real site it was made for. It separates them by storage: synced passkeys live in credential managers such as iCloud Keychain or Google Password Manager, while device-bound passkeys never leave a single device, and it says security keys give the highest assurance.
Privacy kit
- NordPassCreates and stores a unique password for every account.Start with NordPass
Chosen from specifications, policies and published reviews; we have not tested these ourselves. More in the Privacy kit
Your next three steps
- See how long your current password pattern would last in the password strength check; it runs in your browser.
- Move every account to its own password in a manager such as NordPass.
- Put a security key on your email first, then the bank, and keep a second key as the backup.
Questions people ask before buying one
Is a YubiKey a passkey?
It can be. A YubiKey 5 or Yubico Security Key can store passkeys, and it can also act as a second step after your password, the older way security keys were used. When a site uses the key as a second step, nothing is stored on the key, so there is no limit on how many sites you add. When a site saves a passkey on it, that passkey takes one of its slots. Yubico raised the limit from 25 to 100 passkeys with firmware 5.7, which it began selling in 2024. YubiKey firmware cannot be updated, so an older key keeps its old limit.
Is a hardware key safer than the passkey on my phone?
Against phishing, both work. The difference is what else can reach the key. A synced passkey can be copied, which is exactly what makes it convenient: anyone who takes over the account that syncs it can, in principle, get it onto a new device. That is why Apple, Google and Microsoft protect the sync with more than a password. Apple says iCloud Keychain is end-to-end encrypted with keys it does not know, Google asks for your Password Manager PIN or an Android screen lock on a new device, and Microsoft's password manager asks for its own PIN.
A key in hardware cannot be exported at all. NIST's digital identity guidelines, SP 800-63B, revised in 2025, accept synced passkeys at the middle assurance level, the one ordinary two-step sign-in is aimed at, but rule them out for the highest level, because the private key has to be exportable for syncing to work. For most people's accounts that distinction is academic. For an IT administrator, a journalist or anyone a capable attacker would single out, it is the whole point.
Will my accounts accept one?
The big three do. Google lets you create a passkey on a security key that supports FIDO2. Microsoft lets you save a Microsoft account passkey to a password manager, a phone, Windows Hello or a physical security key. Apple's Security Keys for Apple Account works differently: the key replaces the six-digit code you get when signing in on a new device, and Apple requires at least two keys and accepts up to six. Many banks and shops still offer only passwords and text codes, so expect a key to cover your most important accounts rather than all of them.
What if I lose the key?
Then your spare gets you in, which is why you buy two. A security key cannot be backed up or cloned, so the spare is a separate key that you register on each account alongside the first. Yubico recommends registering both at the same time. Apple puts the risk plainly: lose all your trusted devices and security keys, and you could be locked out of your Apple Account permanently.
There is also the PIN. A YubiKey allows eight wrong PIN attempts in a row, then blocks its passkey function until it is reset, and a reset erases every passkey on it. A spare key, printed recovery codes, or a synced passkey on the same account all keep a forgotten PIN from becoming a lockout.
Which accounts deserve a key
Start at the top and stop when the list stops applying to you.
- Your main email account. It can reset nearly everything else.
- The Apple, Google or Microsoft account that syncs your passkeys and passwords. Often it is the same as the first. Anyone who takes it over and gets past its sync protections could reach every synced passkey, so it is worth protecting with something that does not itself live in that account.
- Your password manager, if it accepts security keys.
- Banking, brokerage and payment accounts, where they support keys at all.
- Anything a stranger could profit from: a domain name, a work admin account, social accounts you earn a living from.
If you face more than ordinary risk, Google's Advanced Protection Program is built around keys. Google lists journalists, activists, campaign staff, business leaders and IT administrators among the people it is meant for. You enroll with passkeys or security keys, and it limits which third-party apps can reach your account data, checks downloads more strictly and adds steps to account recovery.
Setting up two keys, in order
- Get two keys that fit your devices. NFC lets you tap a phone; pick USB-A or USB-C for your computer.
- Set a PIN on each. Your browser or phone usually asks for one the first time you save a passkey to a key, or you can set it in Yubico's free Authenticator app.
- Add both keys to your email account in the same sitting. Look under security, passkeys or two-step verification.
- Repeat for the account that syncs your passkeys, then the password manager and your money accounts.
- Sign out once and sign back in with the spare, so you know it works before you need it.
- Keep the spare at home with your printed recovery codes, not on the same key ring as the first.
- Leave a second way in on each account where you can, such as a synced passkey or recovery codes, and consider dropping text-message codes on accounts that let you. Our piece on how your phone number links your accounts explains why text codes are the weak spot.
Which key, if you buy one
Yubico's YubiKey 5 NFC (USB-A) and YubiKey 5C NFC (USB-C) do passkeys and two-step sign-in, plus a few older standards: one-time codes, smart card sign-in and OpenPGP. The Yubico Security Key NFC does only the FIDO standards that passkeys use, which is all most people need. Buy two of whichever you choose.
If you are still on passwords and text codes everywhere, start with the basics in our guide to password managers, passkeys and two-step codes and come back to keys once your email has a passkey.
The one thing to remember
A passkey on your phone is already a big step up, and for most accounts it is enough. Add hardware keys when you want a way back into your email and your sync account that does not depend on the phone you might lose or the cloud account an attacker might target. And always register two.
Related briefings
- Online Safety
The best security key for most people, and why you should buy two
For most people the best security key is a basic FIDO2 key with NFC and the plug your devices use. When a YubiKey 5 is worth it, and why you need a spare.
- Online Safety
Do I need a VPN at home? What it protects and what it doesn't
A VPN hides your browsing from your internet provider and your IP address from websites. It does not stop phishing, trackers or data brokers. How to decide.
- Online Safety
Faraday bag for your phone: when it helps, and which kind to buy
A good Faraday bag cuts every signal to your phone while it is sealed. What it blocks, what it doesn't, how to test one at home, and which kind to buy.


